I think the catchment for Kilmorie is wider (as it's a bigger school) so you may have a much better chance of getting your son into Kilmorie than Dalmain, which might be the deciding factor in terms of whether it's choice 1 or 2. We know parents at boh schools and all seem pretty happy with how their kids are doing. Our daughter will be 2015 intake and we're hoping to get her into Kilmorie on the basis of seeing neighbours' kids at the schol who are clearly loving it.