Not at all. I think it's a real shame that people feel that they're necessary to feel safe in their own home. There is evidence however that shows how gating can encourage people to stay where they live, rather than moving to more affluent areas and abandoning areas entirely to people suffering deprivation.

There could also be benefits with regard to urban renewal if property prices are protected and there are greater opportunities for social mixing.

Of course, there are problems with them, but it is that much different from a block of flats with a buzzer entry? Residents obviously like those as it puts another barrier between the front door and hoodies, making them feel safer. I'm inclined to think that people should feel safe in their own home, and if a gated community makes that possible in certain areas then who am I to object?