Looks like a victory for the borough purists, but does it take any account of communities?

People in Grove Park rarely visit Forest Hill or vice versa, but I'm sure it makes more sense for the north of Lewisham and for Southwark and Bromley, we are just the messy left overs. And from those messy left overs Forest Hill is on the periphery. The combined Dulwich and Forest Hill constituency had Horniman more or less in the centre rather than on the boundary.

Lewisham South is a constituency with no sense of identity and no geographic focus.